

Setting it in their early 30s would have made more sense for their stages of life (especially with Hugh being a successful surgeon, living in such a grand home.) and it would have given a greater sense at how much everyone had grown apart. I also thought the groups should have been at least in their early 30s. The bad: Both Hannah and April were one-dimensional and Hannah was pretty boring. (1) Hugh was the killer and (2) he cheated his way into Oxford! I was thinking it was Will about mid-way through the book, and even when it was reveal Hugh was the killer, I thought he and Will were working together.


The good: I enjoyed reading the book and was genuinely shocked at the twists at the end. I would rank this one around "The Death of Mrs. I hated "The Lying Game", and I haven't read "Turn of The Key". Westway" 😂, although it's not my favorite. "The Woman in Cabin 10" and "In Dark Dark Wood" are my favorites of her, but I'm also probably one of the few that also enjoyed "The Death of Mrs. I haven't been as impressed by Ruth Ware lately (I thought "One by One" was rather meh), but I enjoyed this book.
